Some residents believe curbside pick-up of large items a few times a year should be an option, especially for those who don't own a large vehicle to haul away items such as old couches to the Eco station. But the city claims there isn't enough demand to offer this type of service.
City administration presented a report to council on Thursday citing curbside pick-up of bulky items isn't needed, and could cost an extra $6 million.
"We can't justify that based on the other needs we have," said Roy Neehall waste management manager.
But one resident is urging the city to reconsider. Francesco Sorgiovanni says bringing a load of bulky garbage to the Eco station is a real chore, he doesn't have a truck and has to make arrangements to borrow one when necessary.
"It is a hassle because if you don't have a big vehicle to carry everything especially awkward things like mattresses and televisions...it's just a pain if you don't have a vehicle to do it," he said.
A program similar to this is already in place in many other Canadian cities.
But the city insists there isn't enough demand here.
Currently, residents can dispose of large items at Eco stations, the Waste Management Centre or one of the city's big bin events. But none of those options involves pickup by the city. Coun. Amarjeet Sohi says that's likely not going to change any time soon.
"We need to look at the balance. I can understand the need is out there but I think we need to give some time to the utility to mature and deal with some of the challenges they're facing now," he said.
And while that appears to sit well with some Edmontonians, curbside pick-up would still mean a major convenience for others, especially those who are willing to pay for the service.
"If the city's willing to do it I'd pay a couple bucks in extra taxes to make sure I don't have to break my back doing this," said Sorgiovanni, who hauling six TVs and two computers to the Eco station.
City administration says that for now its priority is not bulky items, but instead weekly curbside pick-up of normal garbage. It believes it can accomplish that at no extra cost.
The issue will be reviewed over the next 12 months.
With files from Scott Roberts
